Fantasy Football 2025: Week 7 Quarterback Dilemmas – Who’s In, Who’s Out?
Fantasy football managers, it’s that time of the week again—lineup decisions are looming, and the pressure is on. But fear not, because we’re here to dissect the toughest quarterback choices for Week 7. And this is the part most people miss: it’s not just about the obvious picks like Justin Jefferson (https://www.nfl.com/players/justin-jefferson/). Instead, we’re diving into the murky waters of debatable starts and sits. If you’re hunting for a specific player not covered here, don’t forget to check the latest NFL Fantasy lineup rankings (https://fantasy.nfl.com/research/rankings).
Note: All stats, unless otherwise noted, are sourced from NFL Pro (https://pro.nfl.com/), Next Gen Stats, or NFL Research.
Start 'Em
Maye vs. Titans: But here's where it gets controversial—while some might hesitate to crown Maye just yet, his performance speaks for itself. After hyping him up all offseason, I’m taking a victory lap here. Maye has been on fire, scoring 19+ fantasy points in four of his last five games. He leads the NFL in passer rating on deep throws (20+ air yards) and ranks fourth in EPA from a clean pocket entering Week 7. The Titans’ defense, meanwhile, struggles to generate pressure, ranking sixth-lowest in the league. This matchup screams upside, and Maye is rapidly becoming a must-start—dare I say, an MVP candidate?
Goff vs. Bucs: Goff isn’t the fantasy darling he was last season, but his recent performances hint at a resurgence. Returning to Detroit after two road games, he faces a Bucs defense that’s allowed the 10th-most passing yards and touchdowns to quarterbacks this season. With Baker Mayfield and the Bucs offense firing on all cylinders, this could be a high-scoring affair. Goff’s upside is worth the gamble here.
Fields vs. Panthers: Justin Fields is the epitome of fantasy unpredictability. In five games, he’s had two duds (under five points) and three explosions (25+ points), joining Lamar Jackson (https://www.nfl.com/players/lamar-jackson/) and Patrick Mahomes (https://www.nfl.com/players/patrick-mahomes/) as the only QBs with three 25+ point games in 2025. This week, he faces a Panthers defense that generates pressure at the lowest rate in the NFL and has allowed three touchdowns in each of their last three games. Fields’ rushing ability—he doubled Denver’s allowed QB rushing yards last week—makes him a solid start.
Nix vs. Giants: Nix has shown flashes of brilliance but lacks consistency. However, this week’s matchup against the Giants could be his breakout moment. New York ranks 26th in passing defense and struggles to generate pressure, while allowing the second-most yards on deep passes. Nix’s big-play potential and rushing floor make him a risky but rewarding option.
Love vs. Cardinals: Love is typically a safe start, but this week he has the potential to explode. The Cardinals have allowed the fifth-most passing yards and generate below-average pressure, while Love leads the NFL in EPA from a clean pocket. With eight of his nine touchdowns coming without pressure, and his recent uptick in rushing yards, Love is a high-ceiling play.
Williams vs. Saints: Williams has been a model of consistency, topping 19 fantasy points in three of five games. The Saints are a middle-of-the-pack defense, but their below-average pressure rate plays into Williams’ strengths—he boasts a 109 passer rating when not under pressure. His steady production keeps him in the starting conversation.
Sit 'Em
Dart at Broncos: Dart’s breakout potential is undeniable, but this week’s matchup is a nightmare. The Broncos boast the NFL’s best defense, generating pressure and sacks at an unprecedented rate (13% sack rate, compared to 9% for the next team). They’ve allowed the second-fewest fantasy points per game to quarterbacks and have given up just 46 rushing yards to QBs all season. This is a brutal test for Dart in just his fourth NFL start.
Murray vs. Packers: Even if Murray returns from his mid-foot sprain, he’s a risky start. His ceiling this season has been just 18 fantasy points, and the Packers allow the sixth-fewest passing yards and a mere 18 rushing yards to quarterbacks. With limited upside and a tough matchup, Murray is a bench candidate.
Stroud at Seahawks: Stroud’s recent performances have been impressive, but the Seahawks are a different beast. Outside of their game against Baker Mayfield, Seattle has held every quarterback under 20 fantasy points, with Trevor Lawrence (https://www.nfl.com/players/trevor-lawrence/) being the only other QB to top 17. The Seahawks generate pressure at a high rate, and Stroud struggles against such defenses. This isn’t the week to trust him.
Tagovailoa vs. Browns: Tua’s season has been underwhelming, with just two games over 18 fantasy points. The Browns have allowed the fourth-fewest passing yards and the eighth-fewest fantasy points per game to quarterbacks. Without a strong run game and with turnover issues, Tua’s upside is limited here.
Vikings QB at Eagles: Whether it’s McCarthy or Wentz under center, Minnesota’s quarterbacks have averaged just 15.3 fantasy points per game. The Eagles have allowed the eighth-fewest passing yards and fourth-fewest passing touchdowns, making this a low-ceiling, high-risk matchup. Avoid if possible.
Controversial Question: Is Maye truly an MVP candidate, or is his success a product of favorable matchups? Let us know in the comments—we want to hear your take!
